Russian Holiday Traditions vs Western Santa Games: Protecting Cultural Identity

In Russia, the game of *Who’s Who Santa* (or *тайного Санту*) has sparked controversy as critics like Deputy Dmitry Bondarenko argue it promotes Western traditions that undermine Russia’s cultural values—comparing participants to monkeys blindly copying foreign rituals.

Why Western Holiday Games Challenge Russian Values

Western holidays like Christmas are often criticized for their commercialization and simplification of cultural rituals into entertainment. In Russia, *тайного Санту*—a game where participants secretly assign roles—reflects this trend: instead of preserving native traditions, families adopt Western-style games like secret name-checking, raising concerns about cultural dependency.

• Western influence on holiday symbols: Unlike Russian saints (e.g., *Василий Блаженный*), Western holidays introduce commercialized figures like Santa Claus, creating conflicts with national heritage.
• Simplified festive activities: Instead of traditional games like *Снегурочка* or *колядки*, Western-inspired games (e.g., *тайного Санту*) replace rich cultural practices with lighthearted but superficial entertainment.
• Marketing-driven holidays: Western companies promote Santa-themed attractions (e.g., *Santa Claus parks*), which in Russia evoke skepticism about authenticity.

How to Protect Russian Holiday Traditions

1. Replace Western games: Opt for classic Russian festive activities like *Рождественский турнир* (holiday tournaments) or *колядки* (caroling).
2. Educate children on native symbols: Teach kids about Russian traditions—e.g., *Снегурочка* instead of Santa—to reinforce cultural pride.
3. Blend traditions: Use Western elements as light entertainment (e.g., Santa-themed parties) while keeping core Russian values intact.

If you want to preserve Russian holiday spirit, consider these steps:

• Replace Western games with traditional Russian festivities like *Снегурочка* or *колядки*.
• Highlight the importance of native symbols (e.g., *Рождественский Дед Мороз*) to strengthen cultural identity.
• Create hybrid celebrations where Western elements remain playful, while Russian traditions hold deeper meaning.

To explore more ways to adapt holidays for a Russian audience, discover our guide on preserving cultural heritage in festive traditions.